An diofar eadar na mùthaidhean a rinneadh air "Svarabhakti or The Helping Vowel"

O Goireasan Akerbeltz
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(21 mùthadh eadar-mheadhanach le 2 chleachdaiche eile nach eil 21 'gan sealltainn)
Loidhne 1: Loidhne 1:
Admit it.  You've always wanted to know what the difference between ''svarbhakti'' and ''epenthesis'' is. Well, that part is easy, there isn't any, they're two terms for the same thing. Svarabhakti comes from the Sanskrit (as in, Old Hindi) tradition of grammarians and means "loyal vowel". Hm ... epenthesis on the other hand is Greek and means something like "to stick in afterwards".
+
Admit it.  You've always wanted to know what the difference is between ''svarabhakti'' and ''epenthesis''. Well, that part's is easy, there isn't any, they're two terms for the same thing. Svarabhakti comes from the Sanskrit (as in, Old Hindi) tradition of grammarians and means "loyal vowel". Hm ... epenthesis on the other hand is Greek and means something like "to stick in afterwards".
  
Departing from xenologomania (the excessive love of foreign words) we have English ''helping vowel'' and Gaelic fuaimreag-chuideachaidh. In other words, we're going to talk about those odd extra vowels that you get in Gaelic words like gorm and dearg.
+
Departing from xenologomania (the excessive love of foreign words), we have the English term ''helping vowel'' and the Gaelic term <span style="color: #008000;">fuaimreag-chuideachaidh</span>. In other words, we're going to talk about those odd extra vowels that you get in Gaelic words like <span style="color: #008000;">gorm</span> and <span style="color: #008000;">dearg</span>.
  
#First question: Do all Gaelic speakers do this? Yes
+
#First question: Do all Gaelic speakers do this? Yes.
 
#Second question: Do they all do the same thing? Silly question, of course not!
 
#Second question: Do they all do the same thing? Silly question, of course not!
 +
 +
==What does it look like?==
  
 
So ... let us first discover when we put in what.
 
So ... let us first discover when we put in what.
  
 
The rule in a nutshell is:
 
The rule in a nutshell is:
{| style="width: 20%;" border="0" align="left"
+
Ø → Vₓ/VC₁ _____ C₂
|-
 
| Ø -> Vx/||VC1 ______||C2
 
|-
 
| ||[-voice]||[+voice]
 
|-
 
|}
 
  
Or, before you clobber me: If, in the stressed syllable of a word, you get two consonants, one of which is or used to be voiced, stick in the extra vowel as long as the two consonants are not homo-organic.
+
Or, before you clobber me: If, in the stressed syllable of a word, you get two consonants, one of which is, or used to be, voiced, stick in the extra vowel as long as the two consonants are not homo-organic.
  
Ok, step by step.  Sometimes we get consonant clusters in Gaelic: rb, rc, rd, sg, st ...  As most people who have done Gaelic for even a few weeks only know, there are some words where you are supposed to stick in an extra vowel when you get these clusters, for example gorm [gɔrɔm]. Ask your teacher when or why and you'll get the famous blank face. Not, incidentally, that that's their fault, most native speakers of any language can't explain why they say stuff.
+
OK, step by step.  Sometimes we get consonant clusters in Gaelic such as <span style="color: #008000;">rb, rc, rd, sg, st</span>.  As most people learn, even in the first weeks of studying Gaelic, there are some words where you're supposed to stick in an extra vowel to break up consonant clusters, for example <span style="color: #008000;">gorm</span> [gɔrɔm] or <span style="color: #008000;">dearg</span> [dʲɛrɛg]. Ask your teacher when or why this happens and you'll get the famous blank face. Incidentally, that's not their fault. Most native speakers, of any language, can't explain why they say stuff.
  
We'll sidestep the why this time but we can certainly tell you when.
+
For now, we'll sidestep the why and tell you the when.
  
Mostly this happens when you get l n r and ʃ coming together with b, bh, ch, g, gh, m, mh.  What generally happens is that the vowel immediately preceding this sequence is simply repeated (exceptions see below).
+
Mostly this happens when you get <span style="color: #008000;">l n r</span> and /ʃ/ coming together with <span style="color: #008000;">b, bh, ch, g, gh, m, mh</span>The general pattern that's produced is that the vowel immediately preceding this sequence is repeated (for exceptions, see below).
  
 
Let's look at some examples:
 
Let's look at some examples:
Loidhne 31: Loidhne 27:
 
| || l || n || r || (ʃ) || ch || Example:
 
| || l || n || r || (ʃ) || ch || Example:
 
|-
 
|-
| b || + || || || || || Alba [aLabə]
+
| b || + || || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">Alba</span> [aLabə]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || + || || || || cainb [kɛnɛb]
+
| || || + || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">cainb</span> [kɛnɛb]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || || || + || || borb [bɔrɔb]
+
| || || || || + || || <span style="color: #008000;">borb</span> [bɔrɔb]
 
|-
 
|-
| bh || + || || || || || balbh [baLav]
+
| bh || + || || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">balbh</span> [baLav]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || + || || || || inbhe [inivə]
+
| || || + || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">inbhe</span> [inivə]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || || || + || || marbh [marav]
+
| || || || || + || || <span style="color: #008000;">marbh</span> [marav]
 
|-
 
|-
| ch || + || || || || || seilcheag [ʃeleçag]
+
| ch || + || || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">seilcheag</span> [ʃeleçag]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || + || || || || Donnchadh [dɔNɔxəɣ]
+
| || || + || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">Donnchadh</span> [dɔNɔxəɣ]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || || || + || || dorcha [dɔrɔxə]
+
| || || || || + || || <span style="color: #008000;">dorcha</span> [dɔrɔxə]
 
|-
 
|-
| g || + || || || || || tilg [tʲiligʲ]
+
| g || + || || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">tilg</span> [tʲiligʲ]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || - || || || || -
+
| || || - || || || ||
 
|-
 
|-
| || || || || + || || dearg [dʲɛrɛg]
+
| || || || || + || || <span style="color: #008000;">dearg</span> [dʲɛrɛg]
 
|-
 
|-
| gh || + || || || || || duilgheadas [dɯlɯjədəs]
+
| gh || + || || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">duilgheadas</span> [dɯlɯjədəs]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || + || || || || || MacFhionghain [max'giniɣɛNʲ]
+
| || || + || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">MacFhionghain</span> [max'giniɣɛNʲ]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || || || + || || Fearghas [fɛrɛɣəs]/[fɛraɣəs]
+
| || || || || + || || <span style="color: #008000;">Fearghas</span> [fɛrɛɣəs]/[fɛraɣəs]
 
|-
 
|-
| m || +  || || || || || calman [kaLman]
+
| m || +  || || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">calman</span> [kaLaman]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || + || || || || || ainm [ɛNɛm]/[ɛNʲɛm]
+
| || || + || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">ainm</span> [ɛNɛm]/[ɛNʲɛm]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || || || + || || arm [aram]
+
| || || || || + || || <span style="color: #008000;">arm</span> [aram]
 
|-
 
|-
| <-> || + || || || || || imleag [imilag]
+
| <-> || + || || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">imleag</span> [imilag]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || - || || || || || -
+
| || || - || || || || ||
 
|-
 
|-
| || || || || + || || iomradh [imirəɣ]
+
| || || || + || || || <span style="color: #008000;">iomradh</span> [imirəɣ]
 
|-
 
|-
| || || || || + || || aimsir [ɛmɛʃɪrʲ]
+
| || || || || + || || <span style="color: #008000;">aimsir</span> [ɛmɛʃɪrʲ]
 +
|-
 +
| || || || || || + || <span style="color: #008000;">timcheall</span> [tʲimiçəL]
 +
|-
 +
| mh || + || || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">falmhaich</span> [faLavɪç]
 +
|-
 +
| || || + || || || || <span style="color: #008000;">seanmhair</span> [ʃɛnɛvɪrʲ]/[ʃɛnavɪrʲ]
 +
|-
 +
|  || || || || +  || || <span style="color: #008000;">mormhair</span> [mɔrɔvɪrʲ]
 
|-
 
|-
 
|}
 
|}
          +  
 
 
timcheall [tʲimixəɫ̪]
 
mh +          
 
 
falmhaich [faɫ̪avɪç]
 
    +        
 
 
seanmhair [ʃɛnavɪɾʲ] ~ [ʃɛnɛvɪɾʲ]
 
      +      
 
 
mormhair [mɔɾɔvɪɾʲ]
 
  
Soo ... I think you get the idea.
+
So ... I think you get the idea.
  
Now what was that I said about exceptions?  Not too tricky, most dialects don't like the [ɛCɛ] (C stands for any consonant) sequences, so they have [ɛCa] eg dearg [d̊ʲɛɾag̊]. The other exception are slender consonant clusters where the second vowel is generally [i], not a repeat of the first eg tairbh [t̪ɛɾʲiv]. The latter does not apply to most Hebridean dialects, so it's really up to you what you want to do. In general, people seem to find the [i] variant easier to say.
+
==It's always like this, right?==
 +
Now what was that I said about exceptions?  Well, it's not too tricky. Most dialects don't like the [ɛCɛ] (C stands for any consonant) sequences, so they produce [ɛCa], for example, <span style="color: #008000;">dearg</span> [dʲɛrag]. The other exceptions are slender consonant clusters where the second vowel is generally [i] and are not a repeat of the first eg <span style="color: #008000;">tairbh</span> [tɛrʲiv]. The latter does not apply to most Hebridean dialects. So, it's really up to you what you want to do. In general, people seem to find the [i] variant easier to say.
  
And I can tell you're an attentive audience because I can see scores of people scratching their heads, thinking of words like Glaschu, calpa and ceòlmhor. Glaschu is easy, it's just one of those strange exceptions every language throws up. Calpa now is interesting but easy to explain because it derives from an earlier colbthach, which had the voiced stop.
+
And I can tell you're an attentive audience because I can see scores of people scratching their heads, thinking of words like <span style="color: #008000;">Glaschu</span> /gLasəxu/, <span style="color: #008000;">calpa</span> /kaLabə/, and <span style="color: #008000;">mialchu</span> /miəLxu/. <span style="color: #008000;">Glaschu</span> is easy, it's just one of those strange exceptions that every language produces. <span style="color: #008000;">Calpa</span> is interesting because it derives from the earlier <span style="color: #6600CC;">colbthach</span> [kɔLɔbhəx] that had the voiced stop but /h/ caused the voiced /b/ to devoice to a voiceless /b/. And <span style="color: #008000;">mialchu</span> /miəLxu/ doesn't have the helping vowel because you don't get the helping vowel after long vowels or diphthongs.  
  
Ceòlmhor doesn't have the helping vowel because it seems to be mostly restricted to single words or words which have become so fused that they are regarded as one element, not word + ending or word + wordSo even though seanmhair derives from sean + mhàthair, the two have fused to such a degree that it is considered one word.  Ceòlmhor on the other hand in the eyes of native speakers is clearly ceòl + the -mhor ending.
+
==And, of course, everywhere?==
 +
And just a final note on dialects - most living varieties of Gaelic do what's described above. However, there are, and used to be, a few dialects which had either very little in the way of helping vowels or no helping vowels, at allIn these "very little" dialects, the helping vowel was simply a schwa:
  
And just a final note on dialects: most living varieties of Gaelic do what was described above. There are/used to be a few though which had either very little in the way of helping vowels or none at all.  In these "very little" dialects, the helping vowel was simply a shwa:
+
[[Faidhle:f-cuideachaidh.jpg|center]]
<br />
 
 
<br />
 
<br />
 
{{BeaganGramair}}
 
{{BeaganGramair}}

Am mùthadh mu dheireadh on 21:11, 9 dhen Lùnastal 2013

Admit it. You've always wanted to know what the difference is between svarabhakti and epenthesis. Well, that part's is easy, there isn't any, they're two terms for the same thing. Svarabhakti comes from the Sanskrit (as in, Old Hindi) tradition of grammarians and means "loyal vowel". Hm ... epenthesis on the other hand is Greek and means something like "to stick in afterwards".

Departing from xenologomania (the excessive love of foreign words), we have the English term helping vowel and the Gaelic term fuaimreag-chuideachaidh. In other words, we're going to talk about those odd extra vowels that you get in Gaelic words like gorm and dearg.

  1. First question: Do all Gaelic speakers do this? Yes.
  2. Second question: Do they all do the same thing? Silly question, of course not!

What does it look like?

So ... let us first discover when we put in what.

The rule in a nutshell is: Ø → Vₓ/VC₁ _____ C₂

Or, before you clobber me: If, in the stressed syllable of a word, you get two consonants, one of which is, or used to be, voiced, stick in the extra vowel as long as the two consonants are not homo-organic.

OK, step by step. Sometimes we get consonant clusters in Gaelic such as rb, rc, rd, sg, st. As most people learn, even in the first weeks of studying Gaelic, there are some words where you're supposed to stick in an extra vowel to break up consonant clusters, for example gorm [gɔrɔm] or dearg [dʲɛrɛg]. Ask your teacher when or why this happens and you'll get the famous blank face. Incidentally, that's not their fault. Most native speakers, of any language, can't explain why they say stuff.

For now, we'll sidestep the why and tell you the when.

Mostly this happens when you get l n r and /ʃ/ coming together with b, bh, ch, g, gh, m, mh. The general pattern that's produced is that the vowel immediately preceding this sequence is repeated (for exceptions, see below).

Let's look at some examples:

l n r (ʃ) ch Example:
b + Alba [aLabə]
+ cainb [kɛnɛb]
+ borb [bɔrɔb]
bh + balbh [baLav]
+ inbhe [inivə]
+ marbh [marav]
ch + seilcheag [ʃeleçag]
+ Donnchadh [dɔNɔxəɣ]
+ dorcha [dɔrɔxə]
g + tilg [tʲiligʲ]
-
+ dearg [dʲɛrɛg]
gh + duilgheadas [dɯlɯjədəs]
+ MacFhionghain [max'giniɣɛNʲ]
+ Fearghas [fɛrɛɣəs]/[fɛraɣəs]
m + calman [kaLaman]
+ ainm [ɛNɛm]/[ɛNʲɛm]
+ arm [aram]
<-> + imleag [imilag]
-
+ iomradh [imirəɣ]
+ aimsir [ɛmɛʃɪrʲ]
+ timcheall [tʲimiçəL]
mh + falmhaich [faLavɪç]
+ seanmhair [ʃɛnɛvɪrʲ]/[ʃɛnavɪrʲ]
+ mormhair [mɔrɔvɪrʲ]

So ... I think you get the idea.

It's always like this, right?

Now what was that I said about exceptions? Well, it's not too tricky. Most dialects don't like the [ɛCɛ] (C stands for any consonant) sequences, so they produce [ɛCa], for example, dearg [dʲɛrag]. The other exceptions are slender consonant clusters where the second vowel is generally [i] and are not a repeat of the first eg tairbh [tɛrʲiv]. The latter does not apply to most Hebridean dialects. So, it's really up to you what you want to do. In general, people seem to find the [i] variant easier to say.

And I can tell you're an attentive audience because I can see scores of people scratching their heads, thinking of words like Glaschu /gLasəxu/, calpa /kaLabə/, and mialchu /miəLxu/. Glaschu is easy, it's just one of those strange exceptions that every language produces. Calpa is interesting because it derives from the earlier colbthach [kɔLɔbhəx] that had the voiced stop but /h/ caused the voiced /b/ to devoice to a voiceless /b/. And mialchu /miəLxu/ doesn't have the helping vowel because you don't get the helping vowel after long vowels or diphthongs.

And, of course, everywhere?

And just a final note on dialects - most living varieties of Gaelic do what's described above. However, there are, and used to be, a few dialects which had either very little in the way of helping vowels or no helping vowels, at all. In these "very little" dialects, the helping vowel was simply a schwa:

f-cuideachaidh.jpg


Beagan gràmair
Pronunciation - Phonetics - Phonology - Morphology - Tense - Syntax - Corpus - Registers - Dialects - History - Terms and abbreviations