Chaidh e dhan chéilidh is mi cho tinn or The mystery of the agus

O Goireasan Akerbeltz
Am mùthadh mar a bha e 06:10, 3 dhen Lùnastal 2016 le Susanharris (Deasbaireachd | mùthaidhean) (Heck, another mindbender...)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

I'm sure you've come across mysterious constructions with agus stuck right in the middle of them. Such a sentence could look like this: bha agam ri dol a dh'obair is mi cho tinn ris a' chù.

Heck, another mindbender...

For once, the explanation of how to translate this and how to use it is simple.

Gaelic allows the speaker to juxtapose two concepts in a sentence and link them together by using is or agus. It is then up to the listener to infer the meaning. Before you get out the baseball bat, that just means you take two phrases, connect them with is or agus, and leave the listener to determine the relationship between the two phrases. No kidding.

Take the two statements above: bha agam ri dol a dh'obair and bha mi cho tinn ris a' chù. The meaning of each of those sentences is clear. Now, connect them with agus (most commonly its short form 's), lose the second verb, whatever it is, and you get bha agam ri dol a dh'obair is mi cho tinn ris a' chù. The agus tells the listener "here are two statements, you figure how they are connected."

The nice thing about this is that you can make quite complex and varied statements using the same construction. The only problem is that you have to be careful you don't make statements which are too ambiguous. The above translates as "I had to go to work and I was so ill".

Using two different sentences, the connection changes - rinn mi mearachd and bha mi 'nam ghille òg. Put them together and you get rinn mi mearachd is mi 'nam ghille òg. This translates as "I made a mistake when I was (only) a young lad" simply because that's the most intuitive way in which these two concepts can be related to each other.

Without a given context, some of these sentences are more ambiguous than others. Consider bha mi a' tuiteam 'nam cadal is ceòl san t-seòmar eile. That could either mean that you were falling asleep because of the music (maybe it was jazz...) or that you were falling asleep but music in the other room kept you from actually sleeping. However, in speech, phrases without context are rare.

Isn't that the copula?

No. Just as a reminder, the copula is the verb is that's used when the predicate is a noun or noun phrase, for example in is mise do nighean. There's an easy test to determine if is is the copula. If it's the copula, then we should be able to turn is into its past tense form bu. But, clearly a sentence like *rinn mi mearachd bu mhi 'nam ghille òg is ungrammatical. So it can not be the copula.

How about the 's in adverbs, prepositions and so on?

Yes. You're thinking of sentences like air sgàth 's gu bheil e beò or fiù 's na daoine a dh'fhalbh. These can appear with the long form agus as air sgàth agus gu bheil e beò or fiù agus na daoine a dh'fhalbh, but the long form is much rarer than the short form.

Other examples would be:

  • corr 's mìle bliadhna more than 1000 years
  • tuilleadh 's a' chòir crùbagan too many crabs
  • tha 's mise me too

So how do I translate it?

Well... obviously that depends upon the interpretation. It's one of those words you can't really give a list of translations for, beyond and. It could be because, it could be although or in spite of ... depends.

It's not that crazy. Other languages use the opposite method i.e. they just give you a blank and you have to imagine the conceptual link. Think of that quote by Julius Caesar, veni vidi vici. It's most commonly translated as I came, I saw and I conquered. Now regardless of your Latin skills, I challenge you to find the Latin word for and in there.

Or an English expression like (say when talking about a headache) - it comes, it goes where you have to interpret these two phrases as being linked by and. At least Gaelic gives you a headsup.

Tasol, i pinis

That's it really. Whenever you come across such an 's or agus in a place where you'd not expect one, think of it as an unspecified conceptual link.

Beagan gràmair
Pronunciation - Phonetics - Phonology - Morphology - Tense - Syntax - Corpus - Registers - Dialects - History - Terms and abbreviations